←Гав!357/716→
"Я уже говорил тебе, что такое безумие, а? Безумие — это точное повторение одного и того же действия. Раз за разом, в надежде на изменение. Это есть безумие. "
Безумие — это точное повторение одного и того же действия. Раз за разом, в надежде на изменение. Это есть безумие. — Альберт Эйнштейн.
_______________
Давайте будем с уважением относиться друг к другу и не переходить на личности. Спасибо.
GendalfGendalf
Отредактировано «GendalfGendalf» 23.06.2016 16:01:39
Дан-Гомер, в оригинале была цитата Эйнштейна.
GendalfGendalf, извиняюсь, дал ложную информацию.
Неуважаемый анон, если для вас быдларь - это человек, не знающий (оймойбогдакактак???) высказываний Эйнштейна, то вы не отличаете культурность и интеллект от эрудированности.
[1] https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin
> ...An early occurrence was used as a teaching reference at University of California, Irvine in social science lectures in the later 1960s. Also found in a 1981 text from Narcotics Anonymous.
Замечание: для "teaching reference" не указан источник.
> An earlier version from 1975, spoken during a public talk by Osho:
> "The mind is always asking you to do something over again, something you have already done so many times before. And every time you see that by doing it nothing is achieved. What else can madness be?"
> And later in the same talk:
> "To be mad is to keep repeating something that has already been seen as useless, as worthless".
[2] https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Rita_Mae_Brown
> Brown did include this quote in her book Sudden Death (Bantam Books, New York, 1983), p. 68, but it appears she was just paraphrasing a quote that had already been written elsewhere. The earliest known appearance of a similar quote is the "approval version" of the Narcotics Anonymous "Basic Text" released in November 1981, which included the quote "Insanity is repeating the same mistakes and expecting different results."
[3] https://books.google.ru/books?id=d6JZryGvfxYC&pg=PA98&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false
> ...; it has also been called a "Chinese proverb".
> Twelve-step groups have long warned about doing the same thing over and over hoping for a different result, without giving any specific source for their warning.
...
> Comedienne Jackie "Moms" Mabley (1897-1975) was famous for a variation on this theme attributed to her: "If you always do what you always did, you will always get what you always got".
...
> Verdict: Originator yet to be determined.
[4] http://throwgrammarfromthetrain.blogspot.ru/2010/10/definition-of-insanity.html
> I also found a 1980 pamphlet from the Hazelden Foundation, "Step Two: The Promise of Hope," which quotes the same aphorism, so perhaps it got its start in the literature of addiction and recovery.
> And of course there may not be an original author; probably these three sources picked up a formulation that had been percolating in the spoken language, possibly in less eloquent variations, just as it was settling into the pithy form we now consider good enough for Einstein.
[5] https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Narcotics_Anonymous
> It might have originated in some other part of the addiction recovery community, since it seems to have been in oral use prior to 1981, being cited in a 1980 text from Alcoholics Anonymous (though the link on google books is to a 1992 revised edition, so confirmation is needed that it appeared in the original 1980 version):
“When I came into the program, I heard that insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results,”
[6] http://millercenter.org/president/bush/speeches/speech-5532
> We have to change in this country. You know, my wife, Hillary, gave me a book about a year ago in which the author defined insanity as just doing the same old thing over and over again and expecting a different result.
Nevermore, ух ты, спасибо за подробности! Большинство источников считает, что Эйнштейн-таки, но как известно, тому, что пишут в интернете про Эйнштейна, верить не сильно можно...
Энивей, это не так сильно имеет значение для этого конкретного случая, и то, что написано здесь на последнем кадре, – один из каноничных переводов одного из вариантов.
Угу. Это скорее людям, которые считали что это Эйнштейн сказал - комикс же последнего даже не упоминает, так что с переводом всё нормально :)
> Большинство источников считает, что Эйнштейн-таки
Кто-то на вики возмущался, что бедняжке приписывают все цитаты кроме как из первой книги Ветхого Завета, да и оттуда тоже могут)